Gumatay got 89 percent of the combined votes of judges and the public, besting rivals Ryssi Avila and Kice. "Alam kong malaking responsibilidad 'to pero gagawin ...
They also sang their new songs "Totoo Na โTo" composed by Rox Santos for Avila and "Angels" composed by Jon Guelas for Kice. He also performed his new song "My Time" composed by Jeremy Glinoga. He was the lone survivor of his team in the Do-Or-Die game with their own take of โI Want To Know What Love Is" by Foreigner.